Product Design Principles: Standardization, Customization, and Quality

The Importance of Product Design

Product design is the process of creating and developing a new product that is useful, attractive, cost-effective, and satisfies customer needs.

  • Customer Satisfaction: A good design ensures that the product is useful, comfortable, and attractive, which increases customer demand.
  • Cost Reduction: Proper design helps in selecting suitable material and processes, which lower manufacturing cost without affecting quality.
  • Market Competitiveness: Innovative and unique design helps the product stand out and compete successfully in the market.
  • Durability & Quality: Good product design ensures strength, safety, long life, and maintains standard quality.

Product Standardization

It means making a product in a uniform design, quality, size, features, and specifications so that it remains the same everywhere. It ensures that the product is consistent, interchangeable, and meets set industry or international standards.

  • Uniformity: All products look and work the same.
  • Quality: Maintains fixed quality standards.
  • Interchangeability: Parts and products can be easily replaced or used anywhere.
  • Cost Saving: Reduces production and testing costs.
  • Customer Trust: Builds confidence as people get the same reliable product everywhere.

Benefits of Product Standardization:

  • Uniform Quality
  • Cost Reduction
  • Easy Maintenance
  • International Tools Compatibility
  • Efficiency in Production

Challenges of Product Standardization

  • Less Variety: Customers may feel limited because of fewer options.
  • Changing Demand: Difficult to adjust when market trends or tastes change.
  • Innovation Limit: Too much standardization can reduce creativity and new designs.
  • High Initial Cost: Setting up standard production needs heavy investment.
  • Obsolescence Risk: If standards become outdated, products may lose demand.
  • International Differences: Standards may vary from country to country, causing trade issues.

Examples of Successful Product Standardization Initiatives:

  • USB Ports: Same design of USB used in computers, mobiles, and electronic devices worldwide.
  • Light Bulb Holders: Standard sizes of bulb holders and sockets used everywhere.
  • Credit / Debit Cards: Same size and magnetic strip / chip system so cards work in all ATMs and swiping machines.
  • Mobile SIM Cards: Standard sizes like NANO SIM and Micro SIM used across all mobile networks.

Taguchi Loss Function

It quantifies the cost or loss caused by deviation from the target performance, focusing on customer satisfaction and quality.

Formula: L = k (y – T)2

Where:

  • L = Loss to society/customer
  • k = Constant
  • y = Actual performance
  • T = Target value

Mass Customization

This means producing goods and services in large quantities (mass production) but also allowing customization (personalization) to meet individual customer needs. It combines the efficiency of mass production with the flexibility of custom design.

  • Customer Choice: Products can be personalized as per customer’s taste.
  • Cost Effective: Keep prices low like mass production but with added customization.
  • Use of Technology: CAD/CAM, 3D printing, robotics, and automation help in mass customization.

Examples: Nike shoes with custom colors, customized laptops (Dell/HP), personalized mobile covers, modular furniture, robots with add-on tools.

Advantages of Mass Customization

  • Customer Satisfaction: Products match customer’s personal needs and taste.
  • Market Competitiveness: Helps companies stand out against competitors.
  • Higher Sales: More choices attract more customers.
  • Efficient Production: Uses modern technology (CAD/CAM, automation) for quick delivery.
  • Brand Loyalty: Customers feel valued and keep coming back.

Disadvantages of Mass Customization

  • High Initial Cost: Requires advanced machines, software, and automation.
  • Complex Production: Difficult to manage different variations in the same line.
  • Longer Delivery Time: Customized products may take more time than standard ones.
  • Skilled Labor Required: Workers need training in design and digital tools.
  • Risk of Errors: Mistakes in custom orders can lead to customer dissatisfaction.

The Types of Mass Customization

  • Collaborative Customization: Company works with customer to design the product according to their needs.
    Example: Ordering a customized laptop by selecting RAM, storage, and color.
  • Adaptive Customization: Standard product is made, but the customer can adjust or modify it by themselves.
    Example: Adjustable office chairs, software with user settings.
  • Cosmetic Customization: Core product is the same, but changes are made in look, packaging, or presentation.
    Example: Soft drinks bottles with personalized labels, customized mobile covers.
  • Transparent Customization: Product is tailored for customers without them asking, based on data or usage pattern.
    Example: Online platforms recommending products, smart robots adjusting speed or tasks automatically.

Product Life Cycle (PLC)

It is the time period from product introduction to withdrawal from the market. It shows how sales and profits change over time.

Stages of PLC:

  1. Introduction: Product is launched; sales are low, cost is high.
  2. Growth: Sales increase rapidly, profit rises.
  3. Maturity: Sales stabilize, market competition increases.
  4. Decline: Sales and profit fall; product may be discontinued.

Characteristics:

  1. Sales pattern changes in each stage.
  2. Profit varies at each stage.
  3. Marketing strategies differ at each stage.
  4. Helps in product planning and strategy.

Factors Influencing Design:

  1. Customer Needs: Design must satisfy what customers want.
  2. Functionality: Product must perform intended tasks efficiently.
  3. Cost: Affordable to manufacture and sell.
  4. Safety & Regulations: Follow legal & safety standards.
  5. Material & Technology: Availability affects design feasibility.
  6. Environmental Impact: Eco-friendly products are preferred.

Major Phases of Design

  1. Conceptual Phase: Idea generation, sketches, and brainstorming.
  2. Embodiment Phase: Material selection, basic dimensions, engineering calculations.
  3. Details Phase: CAD drawings, final specifications, product instructions.

Factors of Safety (FoS)

It ensures a product can handle loads greater than the maximum expected stress. It is a safety margin in engineering.

Formula: FoS = Material Strength / Maximum Stress

Purpose:

  1. Prevents product failure
  2. Ensures safety for users.
  3. Accounts for unexpected loads.

Example: Bridge designed to carry 1000kg, actual strength = 1500kg, FoS = 1500 / 1000 = 1.5 (Safe)

Key points:

  • Higher FoS $\rightarrow$ Safer but more expensive.
  • Lower FoS $\rightarrow$ Risk of Failure, Cheaper.

Quality Function Deployment (QFD)

It is a structured method to translate customer needs into technical specifications for product designs, ensuring the Voice of Customer (VOC) drives the design.

House of Quality (HOQ):

  1. A matrix linking customer requirements (WHATs) to engineering characteristics (HOWs).
  2. Focuses on important features and their technical implementation.

Steps to build House of Quality:

  1. List Customer Requirements (WHATs): Gathered from VOC analysis and Kano model.
  2. List Engineering Characteristics (HOWs): Translate WHATs into measurable technical parameters.
  3. Establish Relationships: Mark strong, medium, weak relationships between WHATs and HOWs.
  4. Assign Importance Weights: Determine which customer requirements are most critical.
  5. Set Targets for Engineering Characteristics: Define measurable targets for design and production.

Benefits of QFD:

  • Ensures product meets customer expectations
  • Reduces development time and cost
  • Minimizes errors and rework
  • Improves communication between departments
  • Increases customer satisfaction

Example: designing a Smartphone

DFMA (Design for Manufacture and Assembly)

It is a design approach that simplifies product manufacturing and assembly to reduce cost, time, and complexity. It ensures products are easy to produce, assemble, and maintain without compromising quality.

Concept & Need of DFMA

  • Concept: Design products so that they are easy to manufacture and assemble.
  • Need: Reduce production cost and assembly time, reduce the number of parts, improve product quality and reliability, facilitate efficient and error-free manufacturing.

Example: A chair designed with snap-fit parts instead of multiple screws for faster assembly.

Guidelines of DFMA

  1. Minimize number of parts.
  2. Use standard and modular components.
  3. Design parts for easy handling and orientation.
  4. Avoid tight tolerances unless necessary.
  5. Ensure easy fastening, joining, and assembly.
  6. Reduce special tooling requirements.

Importance of DFMA

  • Reduces manufacturing and assembly costs
  • Reduces production time
  • Improves product reliability
  • Simplifies maintenance and repair
  • Supports lean manufacturing
  • Enhances customer satisfaction

Stages of DFMA

  1. Conceptual Design Stage: Consider manufacturability and assembly during initial design.
  2. Detailed Design Stage: Apply DFMA principles to reduce parts and simplify design.
  3. Prototype/Testing Stage: Evaluate ease of assembly and manufacturability.
  4. Production Stage: Final DFMA-approved design is used for mass production.
  5. Computer-Based DFMA: Software tools analyze designs for part count reduction and cost estimation.
  6. Robust Design: Designing products to perform consistently under variations in manufacturing or usage.
  7. Concurrent Engineering: Design, manufacturing, and other departments work simultaneously instead of sequentially.

Failure Mode, Effects, and Criticality Analysis (FMECA)

FMECA is a systematic method used to identify potential failures in a product, system, or process, analyze their effects and causes, and prioritize them based on criticality.

Goal of FMECA: To improve product reliability, safety, and performance, and to prevent failures before they occur.

Need for FMECA

  • Predict failures before they happen
  • Reduce maintenance costs and downtime
  • Enhance safety and reliability
  • Improve design quality
  • Meet regulatory and quality standards

Process of FMECA

1. Identify Components / Functions

Break down the system into components and functions.
Example: Conveyor system $\rightarrow$ motor, belt, sensors

2. Identify Failure Modes

List all possible ways each component can fail.
Example: Motor $\rightarrow$ overheating, bearing failure

3. Determine Effects of Failure

Analyze the consequences of each failure.
Example: Motor overheating $\rightarrow$ conveyor stops $\rightarrow$ production halt

4. Assign Severity Ratings (S)

Rate the impact of failure on performance, safety, or cost.
Scale: 1 (low) to 10 (high)

5. Determine Causes and Probability of Occurrence (O)

Identify root causes of failure and estimate the likelihood of occurrence.

6. Criticality Analysis / Detection (D)

Calculate Risk Priority Number (RPN): RPN = S \times O \times D.
Prioritize corrective actions for high-risk failures.

7. Recommend Actions

Suggest design improvements, plan preventive maintenance, and implement process changes.

Elements of FMECA

  • Failure Mode: How a component may fail.
  • Effect of Failure: Consequences of the failure.
  • Severity (S): Impact of the failure.
  • Occurrence (O): Probability of failure happening.
  • Detection (D): Likelihood of detecting failure before it occurs.
  • Risk Priority Number (RPN): Product of S $\times$ O $\times$ D used to prioritize failures.

Benefits of FMECA

  • Improves product reliability and safety
  • Reduces maintenance and downtime costs
  • Identifies critical components early
  • Supports better design decisions and preventive actions

Scope of FMECA

  • Design phase: Identify potential failure modes during product development.
  • Production/Process phase: Analyze manufacturing processes for weak points.
  • Maintenance: Schedule preventive maintenance for critical components.
  • Service/Operation: Monitor critical components during actual use.