Plato’s Theory of Forms and Soul: Knowledge and Reality
Plato’s Theory of Knowledge: Forms and Reality
Plato’s Theory of Knowledge builds upon Socratic principles. It posits that the senses can deceive us, and true knowledge resides in universal, permanent, and stable entities. This contrasts with the ever-changing appearances of the sensible world, emphasizing the distinction between essence versus appearance.
Influences include Heraclitus’s concept of constant flux and Socrates’s pursuit of universal definitions.
Levels of Knowledge and Reality
Plato distinguishes between two primary levels of knowledge:
- Superior Knowledge: Universal (Episteme)
- Lower Knowledge: Particular (Doxa)
| Realm of Being | Type of Knowledge | Levels of Reality | Levels of Cognition |
|---|---|---|---|
| World of Ideas | Episteme (Scientific Knowledge) |
|
|
| Sensible World | Doxa (Opinion/Belief) |
|
|
The transition from Doxa to Episteme is achieved through education and philosophical inquiry.
The World of Ideas (Forms)
The World of Ideas is separate from the physical world, accessible only to intelligence. All particular things, like chairs, participate in the universal Idea of “Chairness,” just as actions can participate in the Idea of “Goodness.” The sensible world is constantly changing, a pale and imperfect reflection of these eternal Ideas.
Plato suggests that everything was created good, and the philosopher, guided by the Idea of the Good, governs. This concept is often related to the Myth of the Cave, where light represents the Idea of the Good, illuminating the World of Ideas and the sensible world.
Characteristics of Ideas/Forms:
- Eternal: They remain timelessly.
- Unique: Each idea corresponds to a single concept.
- Homogeneous: They are not composed of parts.
- Immutable: They are identical to themselves and unchanging.
Knowledge of the Ideas allows us to speak truth about particulars. Knowledge of the sensible world depends on understanding the World of Ideas. The relation between ideas and things is one of participation: things are imperfect copies, participating in the idea, but not part of the idea itself; rather, they are part of the sensible subject.
Origins of the Theory of Ideas
The theory originates with Socrates’s aim to provide universal definitions. Plato elevated this philosophical approach, which Socrates had applied to moral concepts, to a metaphysical plane, giving these universal definitions a place in the transcendent World of Ideas.
How Ideas are Known: Immortality of the Soul and Recollection
Plato explains the possibility of knowing the Ideas through the immortality of the soul and the concept of knowledge as recollection (anamnesis).
Immortality of the Soul
The soul’s immortality is crucial for true knowledge of Ideas. Plato accepts the pre-existence of the soul.
- Human beings are a duality: a body (associated with the sensible world) and a soul (associated with the World of Ideas).
- The soul is the beginning of knowledge; the psyche or soul is rational, as it is the principle of reasoning.
- Souls are eternal, immortal, and individual.
Myth of the Chariot
Plato illustrates the soul’s nature through the Myth of the Chariot:
- Charioteer: Represents the rational part of the soul (the guide).
- White Horse: Represents the spirited or noble part of the soul (courage, honor).
- Black Horse: Represents the appetitive or desiring part of the soul (desires, passions).
Aspects of the Soul:
- Rational (Wise):
- Found in the World of Ideas and is immortal.
- Located in the head.
- Function: Intelligence, reason.
- Spirited (Passionate):
- Found in the sensible world and is mortal.
- Located in the chest.
- Functions: Courage, honor, energy.
- Appetitive (Concupiscible):
- Found in the sensible world and is mortal.
- Located in the belly/abdomen.
- Functions: Desires, appetites.
The Spirited and Appetitive parts are governed by the Rational part.
Virtues Governing Each Part of the Soul:
- Rational: Wisdom
- Spirited: Courage/Fortitude
- Appetitive: Temperance
- Overall Soul: Justice (equilibrium between the three)
What Happens When Souls Leave the Body:
After a period determined by King Minos, souls with a higher degree of purification are allowed to remain in the World of Ideas (achieving happiness). Those who have initiated the purification process but are not yet fully purified are incorporated into another body (reincarnation). The foul souls go to Hades, a region of the underworld, where they pass through the River Lethe to forget their former lives.
Theory of Recollection (Anamnesis)
Knowledge does not come from things themselves, but by remembering the World of Ideas. Knowing is recognizing and drawing closer to the World of Ideas. Concrete things serve as stimuli to remember the Forms.
To fully grasp the World of Ideas, one must understand the Idea of the Good. The teaching method, primarily dialectic (questions and responses), is the means to achieve this, guided by Eros (love of wisdom) towards the Good.
Eros:
Eros enables the movement towards knowledge. This feeling engages the whole person: intelligence, determination, and above all, the love of truth and wisdom.
The Good:
The Good is the ultimate goal of knowledge. It determines what is just, the nature of pleasure, and the essence of intelligence. Beauty is made possible by Eros, leading to the apprehension of the Good.