Maintenance Methods and Levels: A Practical Cheat Sheet

Part 1: Maintenance Method Cheat Sheet

When analyzing a scenario, ask yourself: Why are we performing maintenance on this machine?

1. Preventive Maintenance (Before Failure)

  • Systematic (Periodic): Triggered by a strict interval (time, distance, operating hours, or cycles). The part is replaced regardless of its current condition.
    • Keywords: “Every X km,” “weekly,” “monthly,” “at 100,000 km,” “start of winter.”
  • Condition-based: Triggered by physical warning signs, sensors, or thresholds. Action is taken only when the machine indicates it is nearing failure.
    • Keywords: “Wear indicator,” “meter reading,” “alarms,” “vibration levels.”

2. Corrective Maintenance (After Failure)

  • Palliative (Troubleshooting): A temporary fix intended to restore immediate operation. A permanent repair is required later.
    • Keywords: “Spare tire,” “temporary fix,” “will do for a while.”
  • Curative (Repair): A permanent fix that restores the component to its original, fully functional state.
    • Keywords: “Patching a hole,” “replacing a broken bearing,” “replacing a faulty exhaust.”

3. Improvement and New Installations

  • Améliorative (Improvement/New Works): Enhancing the machine beyond factory specifications or installing new equipment.
    • Keywords: “Installation of a new machine,” “installing a radio,” “tuning.”

Part 2: Maintenance Levels and Echelons

When evaluating a task, determine who is performing it (Level) and where it occurs (Echelon).

The 5 Maintenance Levels

  • Level 1: Performed by the machine operator. Simple tasks requiring no tools and minimal safety risk (e.g., daily cleaning).
  • Level 2: Performed by a technician. Simple part replacements using standard tools (e.g., replacing a fuse or coil).
  • Level 3: Performed by a specialized technician. Requires specific tools, complex adjustments, or calibration.
  • Level 4: Performed by a specialized team. Involves major tear-downs and heavy specialized equipment (e.g., general overhaul).
  • Level 5: Performed by the manufacturer or a heavy reconstruction facility. Includes complete engine renovations or structural rebuilds.

The 3 Maintenance Echelons

  • Echelon 1 (On-site): Maintenance performed directly at the machine’s location on the workshop floor.
  • Echelon 2 (Local Workshop): The part or machine is removed and taken to a dedicated maintenance bay or test bench.
  • Echelon 3 (Manufacturer/External): The equipment is shipped to an external specialist or the original manufacturer for repair.