Fundamental Legal Concepts: Terminology, Courts, and Trials
Module 1: Basic Legal Distinctions
| Term | Remember it as |
|---|---|
| Common law | Rules developed through court decisions |
| Statutory law | Written laws passed by a legislature |
| Federal / state law | Which level of government the law comes from |
| Plaintiff / defendant | Person suing / person being sued |
| Civil / criminal | A claim for a remedy, often damages / government prosecution for a crime |
| Law / ethics | What is legally required / what someone believes is right |
Proof standards: Civil case = preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not). Criminal case = beyond a reasonable doubt.
Four qualities of a workable legal system: Certainty, flexibility, knowability, and reasonableness.
Module 2: Courts
Trial courts hear evidence and determine facts. Appellate courts review lower court decisions for legal errors; they generally do not hold a new trial.
| State courts | Federal courts |
|---|---|
| Limited courts → general trial courts → appeals courts → state supreme court | Specialized courts / U.S. District Courts → U.S. Courts of Appeals → U.S. Supreme Court |
Jurisdiction = A court’s authority to hear a case. Certiorari = A request for the U.S. Supreme Court to review a decision.
Module 3: Podias v. Mairs
Facts: Passengers saw an injured motorcyclist after their driver hit him. They did not call for help and left.
Principle: Mere presence at an accident does not automatically create a legal duty to rescue. But a duty may arise when a person is closely connected to the danger, knows the risk, and can reasonably help or avoid making things worse.
Outcome: The appellate court reversed and remanded the ruling for the passengers. It did not decide they were ultimately liable.
Why it matters: Something can seem ethically wrong, but a negligence claim also requires a legal duty.
Module 4: Before Trial
Basic path: Complaint → summons and service → motion to dismiss or answer → discovery → possible summary judgment → trial, if needed.
TermMeaningComplaintPlaintiff states the claim and requested remedyAnswerDefendant responds to the allegationsDenial“That allegation is untrue”Affirmative defense“Even if that happened, I have a legal defense”CounterclaimDefendant makes a claim against the plaintiffMotion to dismissChallenges whether the complaint states a legally sufficient claimDefault judgmentMay occur if the defendant fails to respondSummary judgmentDecision without trial when no genuine dispute about a material fact requires oneDiscovery tools: Deposition = oral questions under oath; interrogatory = written questions; request for production = request for documents or other materials.
One timing correction: Module 4 says 20 days to answer in federal court. The current general federal rule is 21 days after service, subject to exceptions. www.uscourts.gov
If space is tight, prioritize: The Module 1 distinctions, trial vs. appellate courts, the Podias duty principle and outcome, and the Module 4 terms in the last table.
