Focus Group Setup and Moderation Techniques for Research
Research Group Methodology and Setup
Participant Selection and Contact Protocols
The contact process must be intentional and carried out by qualified personnel. A number of precautions must be taken into account to ensure the right choice of participants:
- The persons contacted must meet all properties listed in the group design.
- The system is often influenced by a person whose views are perceived as more authorized or preferred than the rest of the people (e.g., professional authority, experts, recognized leaders).
This limitation can be reconsidered if the group design requires specific expertise, for example, if the group needs experts or specialized knowledge on the subject of study. Also, contact with people who know each other should be avoided to prevent previous relationships from influencing the discussion.
Securing the Participation Agreement
A participation agreement must be secured with the person contacted. It is common to find resistance, and the contact person must take into account a number of recommendations:
- Face-to-face or by telephone, the reasons for the contact must be explained directly, detailing both personal and institutional motivations.
- Request collaboration by explaining the research broadly to prevent specific preparation by the participants.
- Establish a bond of commitment and explain how the person will obtain a benefit (money, gift, explicit recognition, etc.).
- Agree on the date, time, and place.
- Once an invitation is accepted, it is appropriate to send a reminder about an hour before the meeting to confirm their participation.
Designing the Research Room Environment
The preparation of the meeting point requires adequate material resources, including space, technical equipment, and instrumental recording tools.
Requirements for the Discussion Space
The group discussion space should be as neutral as possible. Rooms designed for this purpose must meet the following requirements:
- Discard socially marked rooms: Avoid spaces that are overly luxurious or unpleasant. The room should be comfortable, appropriately sized (big or small), with minimal decoration, bright, and airy.
- Furniture: Pay attention to the allocation of space, tables, and chairs. Tables should preferably be round or elliptical; try to avoid square and rectangular shapes. The seats must be equal and placed equidistant.
Essential Recording Equipment
The rooms must be equipped with professional tools for recording and viewing the meeting. This includes ambient microphones, video cameras, one-way mirrors, boards, monitors, or portable recorders. In all instances, equipment should be discreetly placed or concealed so as not to disturb the normal development of the participants.
Group Dynamics and Moderation Script
Preparing the Moderation Script
The next step is to prepare the leadership of the group by working on a script. This script facilitates the task of carrying out the research objectives during discussions or group activities. To properly implement the driving script, it is necessary to know its use:
- The script should not be imposed on the group at any time. Its list of tasks or points at issue should not be used as a questionnaire.
- The script works solely for the moderator, serving as a list of thematic topics on which to induce conversation.
- The script allows for verification, showing which issues have been addressed and which are missing.
- It facilitates the work of redirecting the conversation to important issues with interventions designed for this purpose.
Effective Moderator Interventions
The verbal and non-verbal interventions seek to provoke, not force, the conversation and channel it toward the subjects under investigation. There are desirable and undesirable ways to intervene.
General Guidelines for Verbal Interventions
- Avoid closed questions that stifle dialogue.
- Ideally, questions should be open, encouraging conversation, and sufficiently vague so as to engage the respondent and their views without fear of influencing them.
Techniques to Maintain Conversational Flow
In order to avoid disruption in the speech, the moderator should follow the paths of spontaneous conversation, tracing them back to the research topic, and should use specific techniques:
- Mirroring: Verbatim repetition of the last words to recover comments.
- Feigned Deafness: Pretending not to listen to request comments again.
As for the non-verbal interventions, there are many varied patterns, including looks, gestures, expressions of surprise, or feigned ignorance.
