Development Economics: Policy Tools for Poverty Reduction

Development Economics: Policy, Poverty, and Markets

Labor and Capital Dynamics in Developing Nations

In developing countries, having work does not necessarily mean having a wage, as only a minority of labor income comes from conventional “jobs.” Close to half of the workers are engaged in self-employment. Moreover, wage labor is often low productivity work, with irregular incomes.

Capital Pricing and Public Policies

In developing countries, the price of capital equipment is often “institutionally” set at artificially low levels (below what supply and demand would dictate) through various public policies, such as:

  • Investment initiatives
  • Tax allowances
  • Subsidized interest rates
  • Overvalued exchange rates
  • Low tariffs on capital goods imports relative to tariffs set on consumer goods.

Strategies for Income Redistribution and Poverty Reduction

Redistribution policies are policies geared to reduce income inequality and expand economic opportunities in order to promote development. These policies include measures such as income tax policies, rural development policies, and publicly financed services.

Land Reform and Rural Development

Land reform is a policy measure that may be crucial to the rural poor in some contexts. Its purpose is to transform tenant cultivators (farmworkers who work on land owned by a landlord) into smallholders who will then have an incentive to raise production and improve their incomes. But to succeed, this reform must be accompanied by securing access to critical inputs:

  • Credit
  • Fertilizers
  • Seeds
  • Marketing facilities
  • Agricultural education

Progressive Taxation of Income and Wealth

Progressive taxation of both income and wealth is a relevant component of an income inequality and poverty policy. Direct progressive income taxes imply that the rich are required to pay a progressively larger percentage of their total income in taxes than the poor.

Taxation on wealth (the stock of accumulated assets and income) typically involves personal and corporate property taxes but may also include progressive inheritance taxes.

Direct Provision and Transfers

Direct provision of public consumption goods and services to the very poor is an important instrument of a comprehensive policy designed to eradicate poverty.

Direct money transfers and subsidized food programs, along with direct government measures to keep prices of essential foodstuffs low, also represent relevant measures. However, for direct transfers and subsidies to be highly effective, they need to be carefully managed.

Challenges in Implementing Poverty Programs

Four significant problems require attention when designing poverty programs:

  1. Resources are limited. They need to be directed to the genuinely poor.
  2. Beneficiaries must not become dependent on the poverty program; in particular, it must not give the poor less incentive to build assets, such as education, that can enable them to stay out of poverty. However, a “safety net” is valuable to encourage the poor to accept a more entrepreneurial attitude toward their microenterprises.
  3. Measures should not divert people who are productively engaged in economic activities to participate in the poverty program instead.
  4. Poverty policies are often limited by resentment from the nonpoor, including those who are working hard but are not very far above the poverty line themselves.

Behavioral Economics and Poverty

Findings of behavioral economics need to be taken into account to make poverty programs more effective. This is because, in addition to physical health deprivations, evidence from several countries shows that the poor also struggle with:

  • Stress- and environmentally-linked deficits in cognitive skills.
  • Lower noncognitive skills.
  • Greater incidence of mental illness.

A Comprehensive Policy Package for Development

Policy approaches to the problems of poverty and inequality in development need to include a “package” of complementary and supportive policies:

  1. Policies to correct factor price distortions.
  2. Policies to change the distribution of assets, power, and access to education and associated employment opportunities.
  3. Policies of progressive taxation and directed transfer payments.
  4. Policies to build capabilities and human and social capital of the poor.
  5. Adequate minimum wage laws.
  6. Policies to address the cognitive burden of poverty.
  7. Other specific programs, such as: Conditional and unconditional cash transfers, agricultural extension, nutrition, and microfinance.

Market Failure, Government Failure, and Public Goods

Market failure is a phenomenon that results from the existence of market imperfections (e.g., monopoly power, lack of factor mobility, significant externalities, and so on) that weaken the functioning of a competitive market economy.

Government failure occurs in cases where politicians, bureaucrats, and/or the individuals or groups who influence them give priority to their own private interests rather than to the public interest.

Characteristics of Public Goods

Public goods have two specific characteristics:

  • Nonexcludability: It is impossible to prevent individuals from consuming them except at excessive cost.
  • Nonrivalry: Consumption by one individual does not reduce the amount of the good available for consumption by others.

The Self-Interest Standard in Political Economy

Development political economy should consider what may be called the “self-interest standard of rationality,” meaning that people tend to oppose policy changes when they are likely to personally lose by them. This implies that an economic reform that benefits most people may not be adopted when losers are few but have a lot to lose, thus having a great incentive to take action to block the reform (e.g., ranging from lobbying, bribery, and so on). Meanwhile, the many gainers each benefit relatively little, so they do not have much incentive to take political action in support of the reform.

Sometimes the majority opposes policies they would likely gain from. This may be due to:

  • Lack of understanding of economic policy choices.
  • Uncertainty over who will gain or lose from that policy (risk aversion).

Corruption: A Major Restraint on Development

One of the reasons why the elimination of corruption is important for development is that its perverse effects fall disproportionately on the poor and are a major restraint on their ability to escape from poverty. While the rich may pay large bribes under corrupt regimes, the poor generally pay much larger fractions of their incomes in bribes and other forms of extortion.

Institutional Requirements for Successful Development

Successful economic development requires a good performance of an institutional “three-legged stool” made up of the market, the citizen sector, and the state functioning.